The Vote Conscience Demands

Whoever votes assumes a responsibility before God, the homeland and the generations to come.

12–18 minutes
Gravura em ouro velho sobre verde: eleitor depositando o voto na urna sob o carvalho

Whoever votes assumes a responsibility before God, the homeland and the generations to come.

In Brazil the vote is compulsory, and perhaps that is why many people treat it as a nuisance. One goes to the polling station to avoid a fine, which today is no more than R$ 3.51 per round [1]. Someone is chosen at the last minute, and a few months later the name is already forgotten.

Others, tired of politics, prefer to spoil the ballot or stay home, as if washing their hands were a form of protest. In the first round in October, 21.08% of voters did not turn out [2].

The weariness is understandable. But the vote is a serious thing. The Constitution guarantees it as a right, and conscience demands it as a duty. Whoever grasps that changes the way they prepare for each election and the way they follow the country afterwards.

Right and duty go together

There is much talk of rights and little of duties, but one does not go without the other. Whoever has the right to have children has the duty to educate them. Whoever has the right of property is answerable for the use of what is theirs. With the vote it is the same: the right to vote brings the duty to vote well.

Through the vote, the ordinary citizen hands to other people the power to make laws, administer public money and take decisions that reach millions, including children not yet born. Whoever votes carelessly, or does not care about the vote, has their share in what comes afterwards.

A freedom that came at a high cost

Those born into organized elections forget that it was not always so. In the First Republic, the voter in the interior cast a ballot in sight of the local chief. Victor Nunes Leal described that world in “Coronelismo, enxada e voto”, in 1949, and gave a name to the “halter votes” [3].

The change came with the Electoral Code of 1932. The decree created the Electoral Justice, recognized as a voter the citizen “without distinction of sex” and guaranteed the secret ballot, with the voter isolated in an “inviolable booth” [4]. A curious detail: the same article already allowed the use of voting machines [4].

The secrecy of the vote protects the freedom of the one who chooses. It is an inheritance honored by using it well.

What the Christian tradition teaches

For the Church, taking part in public life is part of love of neighbor. The “Catechism of the Catholic Church” says that co-responsibility for the common good morally requires the payment of taxes, “the exercise of the right to vote” and the defense of the country [5].

The Second Vatican Council had already said something similar in 1965. “Gaudium et Spes” asks that all citizens remember the right, and at the same time the duty, to use the free vote to promote the common good [6].

Jesus commanded that we give “to Caesar what is Caesar’s and to God what is God’s” [7]. The Christian does not confuse politics with salvation and does not flee from it either. He knows that just laws protect the weak and unjust laws oppress them, and so he does not remain indifferent to those who make the laws.

Voting with conscience

Voting as a moral duty calls for a formed conscience. Impulse, sympathy and the exchange of favors are poor advisers. A few questions help, and the first is about values. What does the candidate defend? For many Christians, life from conception, the family, religious and expressive freedom, property and respect for the law are points that are not to be given up.

Then comes each person’s record. Promises are easy. What someone has done over the years says more than the campaign.

No one governs alone, and so it matters to know what the party is and with whom it allies. It also matters to see whether the candidate respects the limits of power. Whoever promises to solve everything usually wants everything.

The last question is for the voter. Do I vote out of conviction or out of interest? Selling one’s vote, for money or for a job, is to corrupt oneself.

A vote carries weight

Many say that one vote makes no difference. The ballot boxes say otherwise. In 2024, four mayoralties were decided by a single vote: Fernão, in São Paulo, by 522 to 521; Gentil, in Rio Grande do Sul, by 699 to 698; Olho d’Água do Borges, in Rio Grande do Norte, by 2,178 to 2,177; and Rosário da Limeira, in Minas Gerais, by 2,037 to 2,036 [8].

In Caucaia, in Ceará, eight votes separated second from third place and decided who would go to the runoff, in a race in which each had more than 47,000 [8].

There is also what does not enter the tally. The vote is a moral act. Even if my candidate loses, I have borne witness to what I consider just.

The spoiled ballot and abstention may look like gestures of purity. In practice, they hand the decision to others, to the more organized, who are not always the more honest. Plato already warned, in the “Republic”, that the greatest punishment for those who refuse to govern is to be governed by someone worse [9].

It is commonly attributed to Edmund Burke the saying that, for evil to triumph, it is enough that good people do nothing. It is not in his writings, and no one knows for certain who coined it [10]. What Burke wrote, in 1770, was that when bad men combine, the good must associate, or they will fall one by one [11].

The one who came closest to the famous phrase was John Stuart Mill. In 1867, speaking to the students of the University of St Andrews, he said that no one should soothe their conscience with the illusion that they do no harm when they take no part. Bad men, he continued, need only that good men look on and do nothing [12].

The mandate that must be followed

Voting well is the beginning. The citizen’s duty continues after the election: following the mandate, demanding coherence, knowing the bills under way, taking part in hearings and councils, writing to representatives.

The less conspicuous elections count a great deal. City councilors and state deputies often receive thoughtless votes. They are the ones who decide what lies closest to our lives: the school, the health clinic, security, the use of public money in the city.

Preparing in good time

Whoever leaves thinking about the vote until the eve becomes a hostage to propaganda. It helps to follow political life the whole year, including when there is no election. It helps to seek varied sources and to distrust rumors and message chains.

At home, politics can be talked about with respect, so that children learn to think, rather than to repeat. Those who have faith pray for the country and ask for discernment before deciding. And it is wise to write down the names of those one voted for, so as to follow and hold them to account afterwards.

What the voter can check

There is another dimension of the voter’s duty: to care for the transparency of the electoral process itself. A fair election calls for conscientious citizens, honest candidates and a count that can be checked.

The Constitution sets the terms. The sole paragraph of article 1 begins thus:

All power emanates from the people.

Article 14 says that popular sovereignty is exercised by universal suffrage and by direct and secret vote, of equal value for all. Article 60 places that vote among the clauses that not even an amendment may abolish. And article 37 requires the public administration to obey the principle of publicity [13]. In plain language: the people own the power, the vote is theirs, and what the State does must be done in the open.

This has a name: publicity of the suffrage. Each person’s vote remains secret. What becomes public and verifiable are the steps of voting, counting and totaling.

The surveys show why the subject deserves calm. On the eve of the 2022 runoff, AtlasIntel found 55.8% confidence in the electronic voting machines and 35.2% distrust [14]. In February 2026, Quaest asked whether the machines are reliable: 53% agreed and 43% disagreed [15].

After this year’s election, the question changed. In the AtlasIntel/Bloomberg survey released on 13 November, 52.7% said that the result of the presidential election reflected the will of the voters, and 42.2% said there had been fraud capable of altering it [16]. Days earlier, Quaest had measured 61% for those who said the elections were clean and fair and 30% for those who said there had been fraud [17].

The institutes and the questions are different, and the figures are not to be added up or treated as a series. But, by the milder measure, three in every ten Brazilians doubt. By the harder one, four.

It is necessary to say with the same clarity what these surveys do not show. They measure perception. The Integrity Test of the runoff, carried out at the TSE headquarters, found no divergence between the paper votes and those recorded in the machines [18]. Whoever asks for more transparency is not accusing anyone of fraud.

The idea that the citizen should be able to check has sound foundations. On 3 March 2009, the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany ruled on the machines used in a federal election. It held that, when voting is done by machine, the citizen must be able to examine reliably, and without specialized technical knowledge, the essential steps of the vote and the count [19].

The same decision has two limits that are worth citing. The court did not ban the machines: it allowed them provided there is that control, and gave as an example those that print a paper record visible to the voter. And it did not annul the election, because there was no indication of failure or of manipulation [19].

The Brazilian system has serious instruments, and honesty requires that they be recognized. At the end of voting, each machine issues the precinct bulletin (boletim de urna), with the result of that polling station. The parties receive a copy [20], and anyone can check it by the code printed on it [21].

The Digital Record of the Vote stores each vote in a random position, with no link to the order of the voters, and allows the votes in the machine to be recounted electronically [20], [21]. On election day, machines drawn by lot go through the Integrity Test: votes written on paper ballots are entered in front of cameras, and the result is compared [22].

There is a caveat. Under the TSE rule, those who may request verification after the election are the oversight entities, such as the parties, the OAB, the Public Prosecutor’s Office and accredited universities [22]. The ordinary citizen attends the ceremonies, which are public, and checks the bulletin. The recount that is possible is electronic, done within the system itself.

From this arises the discussion of the materiality of the vote, which is an old one. Law 13.165, of 2015, required the machine to print the record of each vote, deposited without manual contact by the voter in a sealed place [23].

The Supreme Federal Court suspended the rule in 2018 and, in 2020, unanimously declared it unconstitutional. It held that, as it was written, it put the secrecy and the freedom of the vote at risk [24].

The rapporteur left a personal opinion on the record: the printing of the vote record is possible, but “it needs to be gradual” [24]. And the prevailing vote admits that the legislature may choose a mixed model, provided that risk is not present [24]. The door, therefore, was not closed.

On 10 August 2021, the Chamber of Deputies voted on PEC 135/2019, which would have made physical ballots verifiable by the voter mandatory. There were 229 votes in favor, 218 against and one abstention. It fell 79 short of the 308 required, and the proposal was archived [25].

On all of this, I hold with serenity a conviction. The election must be able to be audited by recount, and the check must be within reach of any citizen. Today it remains with parties, technicians and authorities.

For that, what is missing is a material record, independent of the machine, which the voter can check and which can be recounted in sight of all, without putting secrecy at risk. Anyone who, in good faith, points to a problem in the count should have a clear legal path to request that recount.

Whoever loves democracy wants more light. Of the count one asks the same as of a public budget, a judgment or a deed: that it can be checked. The more the citizen can verify, the less room there will be for rumors and the stronger the legitimacy of the result, whoever wins.

A responsibility toward those who will come

The Brazil we will leave to children and grandchildren is being built, in large part, by the choices we make at the ballot box. Each election is a chance to protect what is good, correct what is wrong and preserve the roots that sustain us as a people.

Voting is an act of love for the homeland and for one’s neighbor. Before the next election, a question to one’s own conscience is worth asking: have I treated my vote as a Sunday nuisance or as a responsibility for which I will answer?


JEFD

Sources

1. Superior Electoral Court, “Manual do Eleitor 2026” (fine per unelected round and justification deadlines). Available at: TSE, Manual do Eleitor 2026 (PDF)

2. Superior Electoral Court, report on the runoff of the 2026 Elections (21.08% abstention in the first round; turnout of 128.2 million in the second). Available at: TSE, October 2026 news item

3. Victor Nunes Leal, “Coronelismo, enxada e voto” (1st ed., 1949). Year of the first edition in a review in the “Revista de Administração de Empresas”: SciELO, RAE. On the work and the halter vote: SciELO, Revista Brasileira de Ciência Política

4. Brazil, Decree no. 21.076, of 24 February 1932 (Electoral Code), arts. 2, 5, 56 and 57. Available at: Chamber of Deputies, original publication

5. “Catechism of the Catholic Church”, §§ 2239–2240. Available at: Holy See, Catechism, §§ 2196–2557

6. Second Vatican Council, Pastoral Constitution “Gaudium et Spes” (7 December 1965), no. 75. Available at: Holy See, Gaudium et Spes

7. Holy Bible, Mt 22:21; Mk 12:17; Lk 20:25. Matthew’s text in the Ave-Maria translation: Bíblia Online, Mt 22:21

8. Superior Electoral Court, official results of the first round of the 2024 Elections for mayor: Fernão-SP, Gentil-RS, Olho d’Água do Borges-RN, Rosário da Limeira-MG and Caucaia-CE. Report: Estadão, “Em quatro cidades brasileiras, apenas 1 voto definiu novo prefeito”

9. Plato, “The Republic”, book I, 347c (English translation by Paul Shorey). Available at: Perseids, Republic 1.347

10. Garson O’Toole, “The Only Thing Necessary for the Triumph of Evil is that Good Men Do Nothing” (history of the phrase attributed to Burke). Available at: Quote Investigator

11. Edmund Burke, “Thoughts on the Cause of the Present Discontents” (1770). Available at: Project Gutenberg

12. John Stuart Mill, “Inaugural Address Delivered to the University of St. Andrews, Feb. 1st 1867” (London: Longmans, Green, Reader, and Dyer, 1867), p. 36. Text: Internet Archive (PDF). Office and date: University of St Andrews, special collections

13. Brazil, Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil of 1988, art. 1, sole paragraph; art. 14, caput; art. 37, caput; art. 60, § 4, II. Available at: Chamber of Deputies, updated text

14. AtlasIntel, survey of 26 to 29 October 2022, 7,500 interviewees, margin of 1 percentage point, TSE registration BR-04838/2022. Available at: Bloomberg Línea, 29/10/2022

15. Genial/Quaest, fieldwork from 5 to 9 February 2026, 2,004 household interviews, margin of 2 percentage points, TSE registration BR-00249/2026 (statement tested: “The electronic voting machines are reliable”). Available at: InfoMoney and Diário de Pernambuco

16. AtlasIntel/Bloomberg, fieldwork from 5 to 9 November 2026, 4,946 respondents, margin of 2 percentage points, released on 13 November 2026. Available at: Gazeta do Povo and Gazeta do Paraná

17. Genial/Quaest, fieldwork from 30 October to 2 November 2026, 2,004 interviews. Available at: Estado de Minas

18. Superior Electoral Court, “Integrity Test of the runoff at the TSE confirms correspondence between paper ballots and the votes in the machines” (October 2026). Available at: TSE

19. Germany, Federal Constitutional Court, Second Senate, judgment of 3 March 2009, cases 2 BvC 3/07 and 2 BvC 4/07 (official English version; see especially paragraph 121). Available at: Bundesverfassungsgericht

20. Brazil, Law no. 9.504, of 30 September 1997 (Elections Law), art. 59, § 4 (digital record of the vote) and art. 68 (precinct bulletin). Available at: Chamber of Deputies, updated text

21. Senado Agency, “Urna eletrônica: veja como funciona e como o voto é protegido” (16 September 2026). Available at: Agência Senado

22. Superior Electoral Court, Resolution no. 23.673, of 14 December 2021, with later amendments (oversight entities, art. 6; post-election verification, art. 51; public ceremonies, art. 54; Integrity Test). Available at: TSE, compiled text

23. Brazil, Law no. 13.165, of 29 September 2015, art. 2, in the part that inserted art. 59-A into Law no. 9.504/1997 (veto rejected by Congress; promulgation on 25 November 2015). Available at: Chamber of Deputies, promulgation of vetoes

24. Supreme Federal Court, Direct Action of Unconstitutionality 5889: preliminary injunction of 6 June 2018 and judgment on the merits in the virtual session of 4 to 14 September 2020. Court news item: STF, 16/9/2020. Decision on the merits in the Official Gazette: Federal Senate, Legis. Rapporteur’s opinion, in a copy released during the virtual session: Migalhas (PDF)

25. Chamber of Deputies, Proposed Constitutional Amendment no. 135/2019, vote of 10 August 2021. Available at: Agência Câmara and legislative record

The author

José Eduardo Figueira Dantas

Editor of Raízes. He writes about politics, culture, faith, family and everyday life from a simple conviction: what is good deserves to be preserved, and what needs to change deserves to be thought through calmly.

About Raízes

Newsletter

Ideas that endure, in your inbox

One post every weekday on politics, culture, faith, family and everyday life. No spam; unsubscribe with one click.

Leave a Reply