An honest look at 1889, the end of the Empire, and what that history still has to teach us.
At school we learn that on 15 November 1889 Marshal Deodoro da Fonseca proclaimed the Republic, and Brazil entered modernity. The real story is more contradictory than that, and far more useful for understanding the country today. Knowing the episode without its myths has nothing to do with nostalgia. It is where clear thinking about our institutions begins.
Brazil before 1889
For nearly fifty years Brazil was governed by Dom Pedro II. He took the throne as an adolescent, in 1840, and became one of the most respected heads of state of his time. He was a cultivated man of simple habits, interested in science, languages and education, and he corresponded with intellectuals around the world.
The Empire had a Constitution, that of 1824, with a parliament, elections, parties that alternated in power, and a press that criticised and caricatured the emperor openly, without being censored. The so-called Moderating Power gave the monarch the role of arbiter above party disputes. On a continent marked by coups and caudillos, Brazil kept territorial unity and relative political stability for decades.
That does not make it a just country. The Empire lived with slavery until 1888, an enormous stain on our history, and the vote was restricted to a small share of the population. We can recognise a regime’s virtues without hiding its defects.
Why the monarchy fell
The Empire did not fall to a popular uprising. It fell because several discontents came together:
- Abolition. On 13 May 1888 Princess Isabel signed the Golden Law. Many large landowners, who had expected compensation for the freed slaves, broke with the monarchy. Some joined the republic out of resentment, and came to be known, ironically, as the “republicans of 13 May.”
- The Religious Question. In the 1870s a conflict between the government and bishops who obeyed Rome ended with the imprisonment of two of them. That drove part of the Church away from the Crown.
- The Military Question. After the Paraguayan War the Army gained prestige and came to feel undervalued by civilian politicians. Successive clashes bred resentment in the barracks.
- Positivism. Among the young officers the philosophy of Auguste Comte gained strength, taught by professors such as Benjamin Constant, who defended a republic ordered by a “scientific” elite. The motto “Order and Progress” on our flag comes from there.
- The succession. Dom Pedro II was old and ill, and the heir, Isabel, was married to a Frenchman, the Count d’Eu, who was little liked. Many feared the Third Reign.
The Republican Party had existed since 1870, but it had little electoral strength. The republic won neither at the ballot box nor in the streets, and in the end it arrived through the barracks.
15 November
On the morning of 15 November, troops led by Deodoro surrounded the War Ministry in Rio de Janeiro and toppled the cabinet. Deodoro was a monarchist and a friend of the emperor, and there are signs that he hesitated to the end before proclaiming the republic. What weighed in the decision was the rumour that a personal enemy of his would be named to head the government.
The republican journalist Aristides Lobo described the scene in a famous phrase: the people watched it all “bestialised, astonished, surprised, without knowing what it meant.” Many thought it was a military parade.
Two days later the imperial family was sent into exile, in the early hours. Dom Pedro II died in Paris in December 1891, and asked to be buried with a little Brazilian soil.
What came after
The republic promised modernity, but the first years were turbulent. The first two presidents were marshals, in a period called the Republic of the Sword. Deodoro closed Congress, Floriano Peixoto ruled with an iron hand, and the country faced revolts such as that of the Navy and the Federalist Revolt. The economic policy of the Encilhamento sparked speculation and crisis.
The Constitution of 1891 brought real advances: federalism, separation of Church and State, and freedom of worship. But in practice the First Republic was dominated by regional oligarchies, by the coffee-and-milk politics, by coronelismo and by the controlled vote. The people who watched the proclamation “bestialised” largely remained outside the decisions.
Since then Brazil has had seven constitutions, two long periods of dictatorship and several presidents who did not finish their terms. In 1993 a plebiscite asked Brazilians whether they wanted monarchy or republic, and the republic won by a wide majority. The choice was legitimate, and we carry on with it.
What this history teaches us
Looking at 1889 honestly does not mean wanting the Empire back. It means drawing a few lessons from it that still apply.
The first is that institutions matter more than slogans. Changing the form of government does not, by itself, solve a country’s problems. Without respect for the law, for one’s word and for the limits of power, any regime sickens.
The second is that changes imposed from above usually cost dearly. Conservative thought, since Edmund Burke, distrusts ruptures made by a few in the name of everyone. Lasting reforms need debate, consensus and time.
The virtue of rulers also counts. Many historians, of different schools, recognise in Dom Pedro II honesty, sobriety and a sense of duty. Whatever the regime, we need to demand that of those who govern us.
Finally, there is no republic without citizens. A true republic, the public thing, depends on people who take part, vote with conscience, keep watch and hold to account. The bestialised people of 1889 are a warning: those who take no interest in politics end up watching from outside the decisions that change their lives.
Roots of our history
15 November is a national holiday and deserves to be remembered with maturity. A mature nation knows its whole history, with the achievements and the mistakes, the heroes and the contradictions. It need not erase the Empire to celebrate the Republic, nor idealise the past in order to criticise the present.
A country’s roots do not begin in 1889. They come from long before, and it is by knowing all of them that we can build a republic more worthy of the name.
JEFD




Leave a Reply